Although it took a pair of tries to finally get it right, last year’s Best Picture award went to Barry Jenkins’ poetic and astounding drama, Moonlight. The film focuses on a central character who experiences a life-long journey of uncovering his sexual identity. This underlying similarity also reigns supreme in Luca Guadagnino’s critically-adored festival darling, Call Me by Your Name, which makes it categorically impossible to avoid a distinct comparison between these two cinematic achievements. Yet, no matter how much you try to weigh one against the other, much like Barry Jenkins’ prestigious award-winner, Call Me by Your Name appears destined to end up as a Best Picture Nominee from the Academy Awards.

Set against the picturesque landscape of Northern Italy circa the early 1980s, Elio (Timothee Chalamet) is a gifted scholar and musician born to a professor (Michael Stuhlbarg) who’s gathering research during the summer months. And as his father’s latest research assistant Oliver (Armie Hammer), a strapping American man radiating with confidence and a chiseled build, visits and stays at the family’s residence, Elio’s sexual curiosity begins to transform from an internal passion to an exterior pursuit. The seventeen year old boy eventually confesses his feelings to Oliver and they embark on an unforgettable summer romance that’s doomed by an inescapable expiration date when Oliver must return home to the United States.

Call Me by Your Name is a sweet and subtle examination of first love in all of its beauty and heartache. James Ivory’s adapted construction of Elio’s sexual evolution from an inward curiosity to an outward plea for Oliver’s companionship is a true marvel. And while the film’s ability to stir an emotional response occurred more in a meditative retrospect than in the actual moment of viewing, mostly due to an overly detailed and laboring pace, director Luca Guadagnino achieves his ultimate goal and delivers an effective dramatic story. Speaking of Guadagnino, his eye is spectacular as he captures an array of masterful shots that are emboldened by pristine cinematography. These technical and atmospheric accomplishments are further supported by a fantastic lead performance from Golden Globe and SAG Nominee, Timothee Chalamet. The youngster serves as the life-force behind Call Me by Your Name and he effortlessly captures the undulating teenage emotion engulfed by first-time love. And despite my mixed feelings regarding Armie Hammer’s onscreen work, perhaps a little off-putting due to the clear age difference between the characters, fellow supporting star Michael Stuhlbarg mesmerizes with an unforgettable closing soliloquy regarding intimacy and the important of discovering love in its purest form. Experiencing Call Me by Your Name can often feel like a chore, wading through the sometimes exhaustive nuance of Luca Guadagnino and James Ivory’s storytelling, but it’s also a tender and heartfelt journey that’s worthy of your patience.

GRADE: 3.5/5

For more reviews, trailers and movie lists visit MCDAVE’s new host site

There are certain things in this world that just can’t be explained. On the surface, Barry Jenkins’ profound new feature, Moonlight, focuses on a familiar premise using many unknown actors and actresses, but somehow it manages to transcend the superficial sum of its parts. Being able to pull off that rare feat is nothing to take lightly. And for that reason, Barry Jenkins and his entire collection of writers, actors and crew appear to be in line for a huge awards season run.

Moonlight tells the gripping story of an impoverished youth named Chiron growing up during the heart of “The War on Drugs” in the Miami projects. Chiron is taken under the wing of a local drug dealer (Mahershala Ali) and his girlfriend (Janelle Monae) while trying to avoid his drug-addicted mother (Naomie Harris). And as Chiron comes into his own, not only is he forced to battle the demons of his home life, he also struggles to come to grips with his sexuality.

moonlight-feat

Although Moonlight fails to venture into uncharted territory with its premise or story, the film unfolds in a truly mesmerizing manner. Within its partitioned structure, years pass from chapter to chapter bringing about a trio of performers to capture the essence of Chiron. Each are absolutely magnificent is this evolving story of self discovery and personal acceptance, but it’s Ashton Sanders who shines brightest. Sanders highlights the middle segment of the film during Chiron’s trying teenage years, where he experiences harsh bullying and a unforgettable glimpse into his sexual curiosity. It’s a challenging role that’s captured brilliantly by the young actor. Other standout performances come from Mahershala Ali, Janelle Monae and Naomie Harris. Ali gives a memorable turn in the opening chapter as Chiron’s flawed mentor, while Harris appears in all three parts as the boy’s drug-addled mother. Mounting buzz suggests that both Ali and Harris are the most likely to earn Oscar recognition but, make no mistake about it, there’s no shortage of impressive acting on display throughout the entirety of Moonlight.

moonlight1

In addition to countless exceptional performances that help create an engrossing story, Moonlight possesses flawless pacing and top flight direction. Barry Jenkins delivers a masterful vision that lifts the film from a recognizable tale to a refreshingly original finished product. And although Moonlight‘s stereotypical portrayal of urban drug addiction is slightly frustrating, it becomes an easily overlooked blemish by the time the third act arrives. In fact, I felt completely caught off guard by the film’s final scene, as I could’ve easily taken another hour of Chiron’s captivating journey. Needless to say, the surprising conclusion doesn’t feel cheapened at all as the story ends at a meaningful crossroads.

Moonlight is a beautifully poetic expression of artistic collaboration. The film doesn’t need to resort to shockingly graphic scenes of homosexuality to make a statement. It’s understood that less is more as long as everyone involved goes above and beyond, which they certainly do. Moonlight stands as a transcending indie film packaged wonderfully by Barry Jenkins into a certified and deserving awards season contender.

GRADE: 4.5/5

Check out other reviews, movie lists and trailers at MCDave’s host site