Login/Signup Store Facebook Community YouTube Channel

Geekscape Movie Reviews: Live by Night

Wednesday 11th January 2017 by MCDave

Despite a momentous start to his directing career, one that includes a Best Picture Oscar win for Argo, Ben Affleck’s latest film hasn’t even made it into the awards season discussion. His new endeavor, Live by Night, a gangster flick predominantly set during the Prohibition Era in Florida, represents a bitter free-fall for the previously unscathed filmmaker. Affleck offers nothing new to the genre and any hope that another adaptation from Dennis Lehane – who also penned the source material for Affleck’s phenomenal 2007 debut, Gone Baby Gone – would be a reason for optimism, quickly falls by the wayside during the film’s forgettable first act.

After a hidden romance with an Irish Mob boss’ mistress (Sienna Miller) nearly end his life, Joe Coughlin (Affleck) returns and sells his soul the rival Italian Mob in order to exact revengeon his nemesis. Consequently, Joe ventures to Florida during Prohibition where he monopolizes the Rum industry and falls for Graciela (Zoe Saldana), a woman whose inside connections help build the empire. But as Prohibition becomes repealed, Joe’s mismanagement of his supreme position makes him a vulnerable man in a dangerous industry.

Live by Night suffers immensely by writer, director and star, Ben Affleck’s, arrogance and misguided vision. It’s obvious that Affleck desires to deliver an ambitious gangster film reminiscent of classics such as The Godfather and White Heat. However, a bloated story continually introduces a wide assortment of characters without ever fully developing them. Therefore, once these flimsy characters meet their demise, empathy is never appropriately earned. Affleck’s screenplay is riddled with flaws, but it still doesn’t feel quite as problematic as the director’s unforgivable decision to cast himself in the lead role. Either Affleck’s perception of Joe Coughlin is remarkably off, or he isn’t quite talented enough to pull-off the necessary performance. Whichever way you dissect it, the blame falls squarely on his shoulders. On the other hand, there are a few select moments of captured creativity and originality, yet they’re swallowed-whole by an assortment of mightily flawed approaches. Notable supporting turns are offered by Chris Messina, who play’s Joe’s right hand man, and Zoe Saldana. But by the time the credits finally role – which follow a dull attempt at an emotionally-charged conclusion, Live by Night reveals itself as a sad and rapid decline for a once unblemished filmmaker.

GRADE: 2.5/5

For other reviews, trailers and movie lists visit MCDAVE’s host site